Best Lasagna in Lancaster – Tiberio’s!

I know we’ve shared news of Tiberio’s adding Mama Luciana’s pastas back to the menu but this new revelation needs to be celebrated. When something is so good you go back TWICE in one week, you know you have a winner.

It’s the lasagna, people. I know you love the pizza. And the amazing stromboli. But the lasagna…

Served still bubbling and piping hot out of the oven in an individual baking dish with a breadstick and side salad (with Luciana’s dressing!), this is the genuine Italian meal you’ve been waiting for. Break out of your habit and give it a try. Most people will be able to take half home for later but it’s so good, you’ll probably just keep going while you’re there!

Tiberio’s is located at 416 N. Columbus Street in Lancaster, Ohio. The new ownership group (Bob & Maggie Bennett, Gary & Carey Smeck, and David Foraker) renovated the previous Trader’s Cafe space and reopened Tiberio’s in Spring 2023. They revived Mama Luciana’s pasta recipes and created a fun, inviting space with a big front window counter that opens during pleasant weather. But the LASAGNA!




Filed under: Finds & Favorites, Food & Beverage, Life, News, People
View from Mt. Pleasant in Lancaster, Ohio

By The Lancaster Herald

The Lancaster Herald is a news and media website sharing community-contributed content about people, places and experiences in Lancaster and Southeast Ohio.